![]() |
||
Business Week
By Stanley Reed, with Babak Pirouz, in Tehran
Monday, May 24, 2004
|
||
|
Not long ago, it was a basket case. But now growth is strong as oil prices soar and Tehran eases restrictions |
Running one of Iran's largest Internet
service providers is close to a 24-hour job for Abdollah Fateh, who has
to hustle to keep customers happy while prying more phone lines from the
government. But recently a haggard-looking Fateh, who is Pars Online's
managing director, took time out for a meal at Monsoon, a popular
Chinese restaurant in Tehran. Fateh, 31, grew up in Boston but moved
back to Iran in 1995. Haggard or not, he doesn't regret leaving
comfortable America one bit. "I can make a difference here," he says.
Fateh has certainly made a splash. The Pars Online logo is as commonly
seen around Tehran as the late revolutionary leader Ayatollah Ruhollah
Khomeini's scowling visage. Pars Online's business has grown tenfold in
the last three years, to an estimated 120,000 customers. Fateh and his
partner, Madjid Emami, are far from the only Iranian entrepreneurs who
have found a sweet spot at home. The Tehran Stock Exchange rewarded
investors with 130% gains for the year ended in March and continues to
climb, while businesses ranging from autos to information technology are
booming. "You can double [your business] here every year," says Mojdeh
Abedi, a 32-year-old Iranian woman who five years ago abandoned a legal
career in Paris to manage a budding food additives business in Tehran.
It's one of the strangest paradoxes in the Mideast. One goal of the U.S.
invasion of Iraq was to turn Baghdad into a model regional economy. But
could it be that Iran, a charter member of George W. Bush's axis of
evil, will wind up filling that role?
It's a distinct possibility. Siamak
Namazi, managing director of Tehran-based business consultants Atieh
Bahar, ticks off several factors that could lead to a sustained growth
spurt in Iran if the country's leaders play their cards right. To start
with, Iran has the region's largest market, with a population of 69
million. High oil prices are providing Iran with substantial revenues
(chart), and the country has massive gas reserves to tap for industrial
projects.
PRAGMATIC CONSERVATIVES.
Until now, Iran has been starved for goods, outside capital, and
technology, thanks in part to U.S. sanctions. To date, foreign
investment has been minimal -- only about $2 billion per year recently.
But local entrepreneurs say that big regional groups, which have grown
wary of putting money into the U.S., are starting to check out Iran. "We
are in the best position in 40 years; the only comparable economy is
China. If we could solve our political and social problems we could have
double-digit growth," says Saeed Laylaz, an economist and vice-president
for marketing at Iran Khodro Diesel, the truck arm of Iran's largest
vehicle maker.
The country has racked up growth in the 5% range for four years running,
thanks to high oil revenues, abundant rainfall, and a gradual easing of
the choking economic restrictions ushered in by the 1979 revolution. Not
long ago, Iran was a bona fide basket case struggling to pay its debts.
Now its external accounts are under control, with the trade balance in
surplus and substantial hard currency reserves of $35 billion. The
government is also raising money internally by privatizing shipping,
auto, and other assets.
It's true that democracy took a beating in the February Parliamentary
elections, thanks to the disqualification of reformist candidates and
other strong-arm tactics. But the business community is pleased that a
new group of pragmatic conservatives took power in the Majlis. These
conservatives include a number of business types and entrepreneurs who
are far more focused on economic issues than the curmudgeonly clerics,
and they want to hold on to power by delivering on the economy. "The
right wing wants to repair its image by producing visible, tangible
changes," says Namazi.
The focus on economics by these politicians comes as a surprise and
relief to many Iranians, who feared a curtailment of social liberties.
Women in North Tehran, where the elite live and work, are still walking
around with their hair poking out from under scarves, and single men say
they can take their girlfriends out riding in the moonlight without fear
of being pulled over for a grilling by the police. "Unlike what most
people expected, there have been no major changes on social issues,"
says Amir Mohebian, a member of the board of editors of
Resalat, the leading
conservative newspaper. "Those who won a majority in Parliament are
moderate conservatives."
Just look at the platform of the group that did best in the election,
known as Abadgaran, or The Coalition for the Development of Islamic
Iran. The group's document calls for "respect for privacy" and
"empowerment of women," and pledges to reduce "government intervention
in the economy." The only firm requirement seems to be that the
religious leader, Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, remain the top authority.
Business leaders think that a conservative majority in Parliament and
the likely election of a conservative President next year could end the
gridlock between the Majlis and the conservative-dominated Guardian
Council, which has blocked so much reformist legislation. The business
community also figures that the conservatives will be under pressure to
improve standards of living. The government will want to deliver such
goodies as more mobile-phone capacity to slash the exorbitant $1,000 per
subscription price for service charged on the black market. A mobile
deal was recently signed with a group led by Turkcell (TKC
).
Business circles in Tehran are even buzzing with hopes that the
victorious conservatives will try to shore up their position by ending
the nation's seemingly endless standoff with the U.S. Such a move would
be popular, and there is a certain logic to the notion that just as the
tough-talking President Richard M. Nixon was able to break the American
logjam with China, only Iran's conservatives can safely cut a deal with
the Great Satan. But it's hard to say if the two sides can figure out a
way to overcome a quarter-century of ill will. The most recent point of
contention: Iran's tussle with the U.S. and the international community
over its nuclear program. While the deal brokered by Britain, France,
and Germany last fall between Iran and the International Atomic Energy
Agency to allow enhanced inspections of Iran's nuclear assets has eased
tensions, it hasn't ended the imbroglio.
SHARING U.S. INTERESTS.
Despite the nuclear tensions, the optimists point out that the U.S. and
Iran share plenty of regional interests. Iran despised both the Taliban
in Afghanistan and Iraq's strongman, Saddam Hussein, and applauded the
toppling of both. Since then, the Iranian government has encouraged
local businesses to supply both countries with goods that range from
fuel to cement. While some Iranian factions may be contributing to the
turmoil in Iraq, the mainstream wants calm to return to its neighbor in
order to hasten the departure of U.S. troops. The Iranians reckon that
once the Americans go, a Shiite-led government friendly to the Islamic
Republic will come to power. In an interview with
BusinessWeek, Iranian
Vice-President Mohamed Ali Abtahi poured scorn on the rebel Iraqi cleric
Moqtada al-Sadr. Sadr's troublemaking "is providing the Americans with a
reason to stay" in Iraq, the vice-president said.
`THE INK NEVER DRIES'.
Tehran also has plenty to work on at home. The economy needs more
reform. Billions go each year to subsidies on everything from wheat to
imported gasoline. Exports of non-oil products are anemic, and trade
barriers allow money-losing plants to remain in operation. Government
ministries and religious charities called
bonyads control an estimated
50% or more of economic activity. Economic policy is still laid down in
laboriously negotiated five-year plans. Even when the government turns
business units over to private hands -- as in last year's sale of $1.3
billion in state assets -- it often retains big stakes through pension
funds or other public arms.
Private investors, while officially welcome, face a daunting series of
hurdles. The foreign business community in Tehran is fond of saying that
"the ink on the contract never dries." Nowhere is that expression more
true than in the crucial oil industry, where Iran has been driving such
tough bargains that few international companies want to sign up. Haunted
by its colonial experience with the British, Iran bars deals that give
foreign companies rights to oil. Oil companies can participate in Iran
only under turnkey, fixed-return arrangements called buybacks.
Iran is paying a price for these policies. It has barely found enough
investment for the oil industry to stem the long decline in output that
began after the 1979 revolution. There have been no major discoveries
since the late 1970s, industry sources say. Iran is also losing out to
Qatar, which is working the giant natural gas field that the two
countries share at a far greater pace than the Iranians. Still, the lure
of Iran's fields, which produce close to 4 million barrels a day and
have the world's second-largest natural gas reserves, remains. Both
Royal Dutch/Shell Group (RD
) and Total (TOT
) are negotiating for massive liquefied-natural gas projects, and Total
and BP PLC (BP
) remain interested in an oil field called Bangestan.
The government's pervasive role in the economy also provides numerous
opportunities for corruption -- from tax assessors accepting the common
gift of gold coins to insiders taking payoffs on big contracts.
Entrepreneurs say that, if anything, the demands for
baksheesh are becoming more
endemic. "There is no way we could smoothly run our business without
paying bribes," says Nazila Noebashari, chief executive of Traf Co., a
freight-forwarding firm.
The obstacles are enormous -- which makes it all the more remarkable
that the private sector is gradually gaining traction. Banking licenses
have been issued to private firms, corporate taxes have been cut to 25%,
and trade has been liberalized. "They are reforming slowly, on a
microlevel," says Fareed Mohamedi, chief economist of Washington-based
consultants PFC Energy and a longtime student of the Iranian economy.
"What they need now is the dropping of sanctions so that all sorts of
investors can move in without feeling a cloud hanging over them."
Among the encouraging tales is the saga of Parviz Aghili, a veteran of
the U.S. banking industry who struggled for years to persuade the
Iranian authorities to grant him a license for a privately owned bank.
Aghili finally got the green light in late 2001, and now he seems almost
overwhelmed by the demand for his Karafarin Bank's services. The bank's
assets have soared to $400 million, and it has received the imprimatur
of a $10 million World Bank loan. Following an initial public offering
last year, the company's share price has more than tripled. You would
think that Aghili would be ecstatic, but instead he's worried that his
new investors will eventually be disappointed. "These people expect high
returns," he explains.
Aghili wants the government to lock in reforms before oil prices drop,
depriving the government of the cash flow that subsidizes the economy.
One primary reform would be to dismantle the trade barriers that largely
block out foreign competition. Restrictions on auto imports, for
instance, has led to tremendous growth in the Iranian auto industry,
which this year will produce about one million passenger cars, compared
with 12,000 in 1989. "There is no doubt about it; we have been working
in a closed market for years," says Ahmad Ghalehbani, president of Saipa
Corp., Iran's second-largest vehicle producer, whose plants outside
Tehran will churn out 265,000 Kia, Citroën (PEUGY
), and Nissan (NSANY
) vehicles this year.
Companies like Saipa are making a game effort at improving productivity,
as its workers will tell you. "Not long ago, 37 people produced 10 cars
a day. Now we do it with 16 people," complains Mehdi Kushesh Safa, a
26-year-old assembly line employee. Yet business leaders worry that they
won't be able to stay in operation as pressures from the global economy
grow.
The government's strategy appears to rely on an ever-so-gradual opening
to the outside world. According to Ghalehbani, tariffs on autos will
ease from 220% last year to 140% this year to 100% next. In the same
vein, it now looks like foreign banks may be able to open branches in
Iran, perhaps in 2006. But the Tehran regime is unlikely to risk
increasing unemployment, which is officially 15% and probably higher.
BUDDING CAPITALISTS. The
pace may be slow, but the ship appears headed in the right direction.
Policymakers keep pushing the privatization of state companies to
improve efficiency and limit the scope of
baksheesh. "Our studies show
that economic corruption has had a [negative] impact on investment in
Iran," says Davood Danesh-Jafari, an economics professor and recently
elected parliamentarian. "By reducing the government's role in the
economy, there will be less opportunity for corruption."
The drive to privatize provides ample fodder for the stock exchange, as
IPOs like auto maker Saipa come to market. The galleries of the Tehran
Stock Exchange are packed with investors every day. Some, like
42-year-old Shahab Mousavi, an engineer, have quit their jobs to trade
full-time. "I am very satisfied," he says. "Sometimes I make 100%,
sometimes 200%. What I like is that I can cash in anytime I want."
Hussein Abdoh Tabrizi, Secretary General of the exchange, thinks it's
important to encourage these budding capitalists by providing trading
floors in other cities so that the public can get a feel for investing.
He is trying to find a way to allow foreign investors to participate --
perhaps through separate share classes.
And Tabrizi is working to stamp out insider trading and other
imperfections. He concedes that the privatizations are incomplete, since
government or religious entities often hang on to stakes. "But as long
as we can separate government managers from these assets, it doesn't
matter," he says. If you take the long view, he's probably right.
By Stanley Reed, with Babak Pirouz, in
Tehran